Thursday, April 15, 2010

A New Enlightenment?














Europeans call the eighteenth century the age of enlightenment because it was both a culmination and a new beginning. Fresh currents of thought were wearing down institutionalized traditions. New ideas and new approaches to old institutions were setting the stage for great revolutions to come. It was an age of reason based on faith, not an age of faith based on reason. The enlightenment spiritualized the principle of religious authority, humanized theological systems, and emancipated individuals from physical coercion. It was the Enlightenment, not the Reformation or the Renaissance that dislodged the ecclesiastical establishment from central control of cultural and intellectual life by emancipating science from the trammels of theological tradition the Enlightenment rendered possible the autonomous evolution of modern culture.
Scholars and intellects gained prestige in Western society because they helped topple the twin tyrannical powers of the Church and the Crown. They exhibited bold and courageous thinking--won at such a great personal cost--to allow their successors a level of independence never before known on the European contitnent. Ironically, three hundred years later academia appears to hold an authoritarian sway over current scholars, especially those of African descent in America. Do we need a new enlightenment?


The Persecution of Progressive Black Scholars
by Christopher J. MetzlerGeorgetown University


Institutions of higher education are supposed to be the place where the free market place of ideas takes hold. In fact, the basis for tenure has always been that academics should not be punished for speaking out. The theory is that such speaking out is protected even when university administration does not agree with the content of that speech. However, these same institutions are also political fiefdoms where tenure has been used and will continue to be used to punish those with whom the members of the promotion and tenure committee do not agree. In other words, academic freedom is only free when one agrees with those in power. All junior faculty understand very quickly that the definition of “scholarship” is a moving target and that if they wish tenure, they better move with the target. The hypocrisy of the promotion and tenure process (and I use the word process lightly) is that too many faculty are more about politics and less about scholarship. So, they play the game to get tenure and then when some of them get it, they punish the ideas of others they find unpopular by denying them tenure.
Progressive Black scholars find ourselves in a particular pickle.


On the one hand, we want to advance ideas that look critically at the academy and simply not accept the status quo. On the other, if we are too progressive, then we will be Boyced. That is, we will be fired from predominately white institutions that will reduce our entire scholarly career to a warm bucket of spit. Of course I am not suggesting that all predominately white institutions will Boyce progressive Black scholars. I am suggesting that too many can and do.First, regardless of whether one agrees with Dr. Watkins’ views or not, one cannot in good faith question his credential or his scholarship. One can disagree with it, one can dislike it, one can criticize but one cannot question its rigor, funny, I thought that this is what academic freedom is about. In fact, Syracuse University believed him to be of sufficient scholastic heft to hire him on tenure track in the first place. So, did he suddenly become a less than mediocre scholar after he joined the faculty? Of course not, in fact, an objective reading of his work suggests that he is a scholar who pushes his knowledge to a public that is very much outside “the ivory tower.” Perhaps the problem is that those judging scholarship should realize that scholarship as well as its consumption is evolving and that progressive black scholars such as Dr. Watkins must, if we are to be true to our mission, bring the scholarship to many who may never step foot on our campuses.Second, it is not an understatement to say that Black male scholars do not dominate the ranks of predominately white institutions. It is also not an understatement to say that progressive Black scholars are in the numerical and scholastic minority at these same institutions.


Thus, perhaps promotion and tenure committees should stop trying to pretend that they value our contributions and admit that far too many of them are more interested in visual representation (diversity for diversity sake) than diversity of thought, diversity of scholarship, diversity of methodology and diversity of thought. A reading of that which is considered “scholarly” by many of these committees reveals a common theme: protection of the status quo of ideas by a limited number of elite intellectuals. To be sure, one can argue that there is nothing wrong with this approach. I would argue that in the interest of transparency that promotion and tenure committees should not shrink from stating this since many of them believe it to be true. This way, progressive Black scholars will simply need not apply.Third, for Black scholars, the reality of being Boyced stifles academic freedom and suffocates scholarship. Many of us will be loathe to publish anti-establishment scholarship for fear that ultra-right wing bloggers and T.V. entertainers can influence whether we are promoted or fired. We will also question whether the entertainers of whom I write are adjunct members of the committee with whom we should vet our scholarship before we publish it. Of course, some of them do not have the educational or scholarship credentials to judge our work in the first instance.But, I digress.The losers here will be students who will not be exposed to a panoply of ideas and approach to teaching and learning but to educational malnutrition in the form of anti-intellectual mediocrity. It will also be academic freedom which in too many of these institutions is simply not free.How can institutions of higher learning justify living in a state of educational humdrum? Just ask the institutions that Boyce black progressive Black scholars.***





Christopher J. Metzler, PhD is Associate Dean of Human Resources for the Masters of Professional Studies at Georgetown University in Washington, D.C. Prior to joining Georgetown University, he was on the faculty at Cornell University's ILR School where he directed the EEO and Diversity Studies program.

9 comments:

Ike said...

This issue is what introduced me to Dr. Watkins. I now subscribe to his blog as well as to his Facebook page. The brother is very smart but most of all seemingly very honest and open with who he is and what he stands for.

NICE post, ASD.

nightman1 said...

I bet they Boyce most progressive scholars, with an emphasis on Black ones. The more unlike oneself someone else is, the more willing we are to do him dirt.

And cleansing the academy of leftist is the next great project of the great Right wing propaganda machine, so that is going to be an ongoing problem.

Zhenhong Bao said...

oakley sunglasses wholesale
fitflops sale
true religion outlet
michael kors handbags clearance
cheap nfl jerseys
swarovski outlet
coach outlet store
thomas sabo uk
oakley sunglasses
burberry outlet
tiffany jewelry
beats by dr dre
louis vuitton outlet
lululemon outlet online
true religion outlet uk
true religion jeans
mulberry bags
ray-ban sunglasses
prada outlet
michael kors outlet uk
christian louboutin shoes
longchamp outlet
ferragamo outlet
toms shoes
cheap nfl jersey
michael kors handbags wholesale
coach handbags
burberry sunglasses on sale
beats headphones
true religion canada
nike air max 90
juicy couture outlet
pandora jewelry
michael kors outlet online
michael kors outlet online
20160514zhenhong

Zheng junxai5 said...

zhengjx20160712
louis vuitton outlet
ralph lauren outlet
nfl jerseys
adidas stan smith
jordan 6s
cheap jordans
tiffany and co
supra footwear
nike air force 1 white
cheap jordans
coach outlet
coach outlet
michael kors purses
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
kobe 8
louis vuitton
louis vuitton bags
true religion jeans
coach outlet
air max 95
replica rolex watches
jordan retro 8
ladies cartier watches
christian louboutin outlet
cheap jordan shoes
coach outlet
coach outlet online
pandora charms
nike sb janoski
air force 1 trainers
kd 8
oakley sunglasses wholesale
christian louboutin shoes
lebron james shoes 13
fit flops
cheap oakleys
burberry outlet online
gucci outlet
mont blanc pen

Gege Dai said...

ralph lauren outlet
tiffany jewellery
true religion jeans outlet
hollister
calvin klein outlet
christian louboutin outlet
ugg outlet
christian louboutin online
reebok shoes
true religion outlet uk
hollister shirts
nike roshe run
chrome hearts eyewear
rolex watches for sale
ralph lauren uk
gucci sunglasses uk
fitflops outlet
pandora outlet
hollister
iphone case uk
swarovski crystal
nike air max 90
longchamp outlet
cheap nhl jerseys
beats by dre
nike air huarache
air max 90
beats by dre
dior outlet
michael kors outlet online store
coach outlet online
coach outlet online
michael kors handbags
louboutin pas cher
basketball shoes,basketball sneakers,lebron james shoes,sports shoes,kobe bryant shoes,kobe sneakers,nike basketball shoes,running shoes,mens sport shoes,nike shoes
0727jianxiang

Meiqing Xu said...

cheap oakley sunglasses
rolex daytona
ralph lauren outlet
asics shoes
timberlands
ugg boots
rolex replica watches
true religion jeans
mcm outlet
cheap jordans
coach outlet online
cheap ray ban sunglasses
cheap ugg boots
cheap nhl jerseys
celine outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
michael kors outlet clearance
ray ban sunglasses
christian louboutin outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet
gucci outlet
coach outlet online
true religion jeans
nike roshe run women
oakley sunglasses
oakley sunglasses
babyliss flat iron
air jordan shoes
true religion jeans
converse shoes
true religion outlet
oakley sunglasses outlet
adidas shoes
chi flat iron
louboutin
ZHUO20160818

dong dong23 said...

coach outlet store online clearances
cheap ray ban sunglasses
ralph lauren outlet
hollister kids
christian louboutin sale
louboutin pas cher
ysl bags
hermes belt
coach outlet store online
true religion jeans
2017.3.14chenlixiang

Jian Zhuo said...

toms outlet store
ray ban sunglasses discount
coach factory outlet online
pandora charms sale clearance
longchamp bags
michael kors outlet store
wireless beats headphones
nike flyknit
yeezy boost
coach handbags outlet
170513yueqin

Jian Zhuo said...

rolex replica watches
yeezy shoes
polo ralph lauren outlet
longchamp handbags
coach factory outlet online
sac longchamp
coach factory outlet online
michael kors outlet clearance
birkenstock outlet
adidas outlet online
170622yueqin